It has been observed that the American Civil War in the
1860s was the
last war fought prior to widespread acceptance of the modern theory of
germs as the cause of illnesses. In fact, the Civil War was
probably the last great gathering of human beings into close contact
prior to the development of the germ theory of disease. As a
result of the lack of knowledge about what causes disease, many of
those men who were caught up in the activities of warfare died, not of
bullets and cannonballs, but of diseases so common as to be considered
"childhood" diseases by more modern standards.
When thousands of men were gathered up in camps, they were extremely
susceptible to communicable disease especially during the first few
months of their service. Those from rural sections were more
susceptible — and the younger men were very susceptible to
communicable disease.
During the Civil War more men suffered from disease than from battle
wounds — some researchers put the numbers at approximately 4 to
1. For every one felled by battle, four were made incapable of
fighting from infectious disease. It is estimated that about
110,000 Union soldiers died from battle wounds but more than 250,000
Union men died from disease.
Among the dead from disease in the First Alabama Cavalry USA were
several Northwest Alabama volunteers. Many of these men died
within the first few months of their service. The first disease
epidemic to usually hit a new regiment of soldiers, especially
volunteers from isolated rural locations, was measles. The lack
of knowledge about what caused this disease when combined with poor
sanitation, poor diet, crowded living conditions, and improper care
often meant that measles would create complications, especially
pneumonia, from which many would die.
In an attempt to examine the impact of communicable disease on a group
of rural volunteers in a military encampment during the early part of
the Civil War, the service records [as published by Todd]
were
studied. Death records from the First Alabama Cavalry USA were
examined for the months of September, October, November, December 1862
and January 1863 at the unit's encampment in Nashville, TN, to
determine the effect of communicable disease on the death rate.
Information was extracted to determine the dead soldier's name, his
age, where he enlisted, the disease the military medical staff stated
as the cause of death, and the recruit's place of birth.
In Nashville alone during those five months studied, 66 soldiers
from this single military unit died. Measles [or rubeola] was the
major cause listed for those deaths; and the younger the man, the more
likely he was to die of communicable disease. The majority of the
dead men were enlisted at Huntsville, AL, and most can be presumed
to be farmers from throughout the northwest part of Alabama. The
place of birth stated in the military records of the dead men give some
indication of where they were from (although the service record does
not state where they lived at the time of enlistment) — Morgan County,
Walker County, Fayette County and Lawrence County are the most
frequent birth counties listed. Some of the military records have
additional notes which indicate that several of the men who died were
residing in Marion, Walker and Fayette counties at the time of
enlistment.
All of the deaths in the First Alabama Cavalry USA during September
1862 through
January 1863 were of troops who were designated as being in either
Company I or Company K. It is possible that the other companies
of the First Alabama Cavalry USA had not yet been created at the time
of the
encampment in Nashville. Company I had 30 men to die during the
five months from which data were extracted for this study; Company K
had 36 deaths during the same time period. The Union volunteers
that formed these companies were recruited primarily from North Alabama
and as soon as the units were formed, they were stationed at or near
Fort Campbell, Nashville, TN. Within just a few weeks of
the unit's formation, disease became rampant and the 66 deaths from
Company I and Company K resulted.
The earliest deaths during the Nashville encampment for the First
Alabama Cavalry USA occurred in September 1862. Three men died
(the first death
was on the 3rd of September; the second death was on the 9th of Typhoid
fever; and the third death from was on the 26th of Rubeola). The
first soldier to die was an 18-year-old from Walker County, AL; his
cause of death is not listed. The second man to die was a
28-year-old who was born in Morgan County, AL, and enlisted in Decatur,
AL. The third was a 38-year-old soldier who enlisted in
Huntsville but was born in Green County, GA. These three deaths
in September were a prelude to the deaths to come in October (29
deaths), November (17 deaths) and December (13 deaths). By
January, only four deaths were reported from the Nashville encampment;
the epidemic had run its course. No records were examined to
determine the number of soldiers ill from disease but who recovered.
Among those dying from disease were brothers, cousins, fathers and sons
(and possibly one case of a grandfather and his grandson), uncles and
nephews. Their ages range from 18 (but probably some were younger
and mis-stated their true age upon enlistment) to the eldest, 68.
Most were described as farmers.
My relative, Martin V. Thornton,
died in Nashville in November
1862. His circumstances are typical for the majority of the
others of his unit who died — young (Martin was 19), from a rural
background (Martin was a farmer from Fayette/Walker County, AL), new
recruit (Martin had been in service only four months when he died),
death
from complications of rubeola or measles (Martin died of rubeola).
The cause of death was not listed on 25 of the soldiers during
the months of September, October, November, December 1862 and January
1863. It is assumed that the majority of those deaths were due to
illness rather than warfare — there is no record of which I am aware
to indicate that any of the early volunteers of the First Alabama
Cavalry USA
were engaged in battle during the time examined in this study. In
fact, there is evidence to suggest that the First Alabama Cavalry USA
was not
armed with weapons until later in 1863. A closer examination of
each service record of these dead soldiers' in Washington, D.C.,
probably would clarify the cause of death for some of those
25. Readers are cautioned, however, that military
records from that time are not complete in many cases.
In the tables below are summaries of the data dealing with the
66 deaths in the First Alabama Cavalry USA in or near Nashville, TN,
during the months of September, October, November, December 1862 and
January 1863. The names of the 66 men who died are
listed. Perhaps you will recognize some of the surnames.
Table 1
Number of Deaths by Company, 1st Ala Cav USA
September 1862 - January 1863
Deaths in Company I |
30 |
Deaths in Company K |
36 |
Table 2
Number of Deaths by Age of
Soldiers, 1st Ala Cav USA
September 1862 - January 1863
YRS
OF AGE |
#
DEAD |
18-19-20-21 |
25 |
22-23-24-25 |
12 |
26-27-28-29 |
08 |
30-31-32-33 |
08 |
34-35-36-37 |
02 |
38-39-40-41 |
02 |
42-43-44-45 |
04 |
46-47-48-49 |
02 |
50-51-52-53 |
01 |
54-55-56-57 |
01 |
58-59-60-61 |
00 |
62-63-64-65 |
00 |
66-67-68-69 |
01 |
Table 3
Place of Birth for Soldiers of 1st
Ala Cav USA Who Died
September 1862 - January 1863*
PLACE
OF BIRTH |
#
|
Morgan Co., AL |
19 |
Walker Co., AL |
07 |
Fayette Co., AL |
05 |
Lawrence Co., AL |
05 |
Blount Co., AL
|
04 |
All other AL counties |
04 |
TN
counties |
07 |
GA
counties |
04 |
SC
counties |
02 |
NC
counties |
03 |
VA
counties |
01 |
Not stated in record
|
05 |
* Record does not indicate place of
residence at time of enlistment but
only
in a few of the service records. Additional notes to the records
show, however, that several of the soldiers were residing in Marion,
Fayette and Walker counties at time of enlistment.
Table 4
Cause of Death for Soldiers of 1st
Ala Cav USA
September 1862 - January 1863
CAUSE
OF DEATH
|
#
|
Rubeola |
23 |
Measles |
03 |
Rubeola/Typhoid fever |
01 |
Pneumonia/measles |
01 |
Pneumonia |
03 |
Acute bronchitis |
01 |
Bronchitis |
01 |
Disease |
03 |
Hepatitis |
01 |
Intermittent fever |
01 |
Typhoid
fever |
03 |
Cause not stated |
25 |
Table 5
Number of Deaths by Month, 1st Ala
Cav USA
Nashville, TN
MONTH
|
#
|
September 1862 |
03 |
October 1862 |
29 |
November 1862 |
17 |
December 1862 |
13 |
January 1863 |
04 |
Table 6
Enlistment Site for 1st Ala Cav
USA Soldiers Who Died
September 1862 - January 1863
LOCATION |
# |
Huntsville,
AL |
57 |
Decatur,
AL |
05 |
Limestone Co., AL |
04 |
Table 7
Name, Age, Birthplace, Cause of
Death, of 66 Troops of
the 1st Ala Cav USA
Who Died of Disease
in or Near Nashville, TN
September 1862 - January 1863
#
|
NAME
|
AGE
|
BIRTHPLACE
|
CAUSE
|
ENROLLED
|
1.
|
Bain,
Aldred |
25 |
Not stated |
Not
stated |
Huntsville, AL |
2. |
Bain, John D.H. |
24 |
Morgan Co., AL |
Not stated |
Huntsville, AL |
3. |
Blevins,
Dillard |
26 |
Walker Co.,
AL |
Measles |
Huntsville, AL |
4. |
Brooks, John
A. |
28 |
Lauderdale Co., AL |
Measles |
Huntsville, AL |
5. |
Brown,
Elijah
|
44 |
Lawrence Co., AL |
Not stated |
Huntsville, AL |
6. |
Brown,
William |
28 |
Lawrence Co., AL |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
7. |
Calvert,
Ralphord |
30 |
Winston Co.,
AL |
Not
stated |
Huntsville, AL |
8. |
Campbell,
Adam |
24 |
Pendleton,
SC |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
9. |
Campbell, Alexander |
30 |
Pendleton Dist., SC |
Bronchitis |
Huntsville, AL |
10. |
Canady, Isaac
A. |
33 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Not
stated |
Huntsville, AL |
11. |
Davis,
Archibald |
18 |
Blount Co.,
AL |
Disease |
Huntsville, AL |
12. |
Davis,
Jesse
|
25 |
Surry Co.,
NC |
Disease |
Huntsville, AL |
13. |
Davis,
Robert
|
18 |
Surry Co.,
NC |
Typhoid
Fever |
Huntsville,
AL |
14. |
Edwards,
James |
32 |
Morgan Co., AL |
Disease |
Huntsville, AL |
15. |
Felton,
Abraham |
30 |
Paulding Co.,
GA |
Typhoid
fever |
Huntsville, AL |
16. |
Finerty, Thomas W. |
36 |
Rockingham,
VA |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
17. |
Hallmark, George W. |
22 |
Fayette Co.,
AL |
Typhoid
fever |
Huntsville, AL |
18. |
Hightower,
Monroe |
19 |
Gilmer Co.,
GA |
Not
stated |
Huntsville, AL |
19. |
Inman,
Henry |
51 |
Lincoln Co.,
TN |
Not
stated |
Huntsville, AL |
20. |
Jaggers, Benjamin F. |
30 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Measles |
Huntsville, AL |
21. |
Jett,
Isaac |
28 |
Jackson Co.,
AL |
Intermittent
fever |
Huntsville, AL |
22. |
Jones, John
B. |
20 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Pneumonia |
Decatur, AL |
23. |
Jones, McDonald (Thos.) |
28 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Typhoid
Fever |
Decatur, AL |
24. |
Lawrence, William F.A. |
38 |
Green Co.,
GA |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
25. |
Lentz, John
P. |
18 |
Lauderdale Co., AL |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
26. |
Logan, James
M. |
27 |
Fayette Co.,
AL |
Pneumonia |
Limestone Co., AL |
27. |
Lott, Simeon
H. |
18 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Rubeola |
Decatur, AL |
28. |
Martin,
Daniel |
54 |
Hawkins Co.,
TN |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
29. |
Martin, Nathaniel G. |
25 |
Lawrence Co.,
AL
|
Not
stated |
Huntsville, AL |
30. |
McColloch,* Leroy M. |
19 |
Lawrence Co.,
AL |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
31. |
McColloch, Samuel |
45 |
Lincoln Co., TN |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
32. |
McWhirter, Andrew F. |
44 |
Warren Co.,
TN |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
33. |
McWhirter, George W. |
18
|
Walker
Co., AL |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
34. |
Miles, William
H. |
20 |
Lincoln Co.,
TN |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
35. |
Milligan, William
K. |
21 |
Not
stated |
Pneumonia |
Huntsville, AL |
36. |
Mitchell, John
C.
|
18 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Not stated |
Huntsville, AL |
37. |
Mooney, Peter,
C. |
18 |
Walker Co.,
AL
|
Rubeola |
Decatur, AL |
38. |
Nelson, Thomas M. |
25 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Rubeola
|
Huntsville, AL |
39. |
Oden, Andrew
J. |
25 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Not stated |
Huntsville, AL |
40. |
Pettus, Egbert
J. |
21 |
Not
stated |
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
41. |
Rhone, John
R. |
40 |
Walton Co.,
GA |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
42. |
Riggs,
James |
18 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
43. |
Russell, George W. |
31 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
44. |
Russell, James
J. |
25 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Pneumonia |
Huntsville, AL |
45. |
Self, Allen
J. |
18 |
Walker Co.,
AL |
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
46. |
Self, Allen
R.
|
49 |
Bledsoe Co.,
TN |
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
47. |
Self, Martin
D. |
20 |
Blount Co.,
AL |
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
48. |
Self, Matthew
G. |
26 |
Blount Co.,
AL |
Acute bronchitis |
Huntsville, AL |
49. |
Sheets, John
T. |
21 |
Not
stated |
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
50. |
Smith,
Allen |
68 |
Pitt Co.,
NC |
Rubeola |
Limestone Co., AL |
51. |
Smith, John
M. |
19 |
Fayette Co.,
AL |
Rubeola |
Limestone Co., AL |
52. |
Smith, Matthew J. |
21 |
Fayette Co.,
AL |
Rubeola |
Limestone Co., AL |
53. |
Speegle, Carroll K. |
23 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
54. |
Speegle, Thomas C. |
19 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
55. |
Stanton, Elijah
A. |
20 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
56. |
Stanton,
John |
21 |
Walker Co.,
AL
|
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
57. |
Stephenson, Joseph |
26 |
Morgan
Co., AL
|
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
58. |
Stewart, Andrew J. |
34 |
Walker Co.,
AL |
Hepatitis |
Huntsville, AL |
59. |
Stringer,
James |
49 |
Not
stated |
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
60. |
Swan,
Lambert |
18 |
Walker Co.,
AL
|
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
61. |
Tedford, Thomas J.
|
44 |
Lawrence Co.,
AL |
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
62. |
Thornton, Martin V. |
19 |
Fayette Co.,
AL |
Rubeola |
Decatur, AL |
63. |
Turrentine, Martin F. |
22 |
Morgan Co.,
AL
|
Not stated
|
Huntsville, AL |
64. |
Woodall, William E. |
32 |
Morgan Co.,
AL |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
65. |
Wood, Joseph R. |
19 |
Blount Co.,
AL |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
66. |
York, Marion
L. |
23 |
Giles Co.,
TN |
Rubeola |
Huntsville, AL |
_____________________________________
* Spelling varies. The surname
is recorded as both McColloch and McCulloch in Todd's work. Other similar
surnames are spelled McCullough.
The data for this report was extracted from Glenda
McWhirter Todd, First Alabama
Cavalry USA: Homage to Patriotism,
(Heritage Books, Inc., 1999). Chapter 7, pp. 71–88, lists the
names
of the soldiers who died by place and date. Because the unit was
encamped at Nashville during the time frame I wished to examine,
information from pp. 82–85 was studied to determine the names of those
who died during September 1862 through January 1863. Those names
were then selected from the roster of the soldiers in Chapter 10, pp.
165–396 and the age, cause of death, place of birth, and enlistment
location noted.
Some of the general background material concerning
the germ theory of disease and the American Civil War was taken from my
remarks at the memorial service for Martin
V. Thornton on the occasion
of the 140th anniversary of his death, November 10, 2002, and
previously published in The Thornton
News, Issue 10, November 18, 2002.
Most of the material in this article was previously
published in the article "A Study of the Fifty-nine Soldiers of the
First Alabama Cavalry USA Who Died During the Unit's Encampment at
Nashville, Tennessee, October, November, and December 1862," in The
Thornton News, Issue 44, May 2005. ~ W.T.
"Terry" Thornton